The CMOInfluence Gap
How sequencing and the illusion of alignment are holding marketing back
Created by
With an ever-expanding remit, CMOs are now expected to be futurists, technologists, and operators, overseeing everything from sales enablement and product to customer experience and AI adoption. In theory, that breadth should translate to a bigger role in shaping the business. New research from GALE and NewtonX suggests it hasn’t.
Across C-suite executives – including CMOs, CEOs, CTOs, and CIOs at companies ranging from $100 million to more than $1 billion in revenue – the data tells two different stories depending on which question you ask. Ask about alignment, and the C-suite agrees: 81% of executives rate marketing/C-suite alignment a 4 or 5 out of 5, and CMOs and their peers rate it similarly high. Ask about influence, and that agreement falls apart. While exceptions certainly exist, it reflects a broader problem: Marketing is too often seen as the function that makes the building look good, rather than one that helps build its foundation.
Split on Influence
The gap between the two questions is worth exploring. Nearly three in four marketing leaders rate their influence on major enterprise strategy decisions highly, while only half of their fellow executives agree. Executives broadly report feeling aligned, but far fewer agree that marketing actually moves decisions. That contradiction suggests that presence at the table and participation in the decision are being treated as the same thing by one side of the room and as two different things by the other. The presence data makes the point sharper, and org structure doesn’t explain it away. CMOs report regular board participation at a materially lower rate than their peers (71% vs 92%), despite marketing being this group’s leading named owner of customer and market insights. Marketing holds information the business needs, but it doesn’t consistently have a seat where that information should be leveraged.
Influence of the CMO role on major enterprise strategy decisions
1–5 scale
Rated 5
Rated 4
CMO self-rating (n=21)
43%
28%
71%
Other C-suite rating (n=38)
18%
32%
50%
Architect or Executor
The gap widens at the extremes. Nearly half of marketing leaders rate their own influence a perfect 5, while only 18% of their C-suite peers agree. The divide traces to two incompatible job definitions. CMOs see themselves as architects of strategic direction; peers see a function that executes strategy set elsewhere.
Performance evaluation reflects the same split. Marketing leaders describe a finance-grade scorecard: pipeline, acquisition cost, payback, and lifetime value. Their peers apply a simpler test, either top-line revenue or softer signals like brand recognition and satisfaction, and nearly a third say marketing is judged on soft, qualitative or unclear measures, twice the rate CMOs report.
Strategy is usually set by others in the organization, and they’re helping execute and design around that strategy — not develop the strategy.”
– COO, utilities company
I think from a strategic standpoint…CMO is almost at the bottom, if not the bottom, in the organizations I’ve seen.”
– CIO, automotive company
Some executives admitted to deliberately excluding marketing from key decisions, in the interest of moving faster, for example, even while acknowledging that the trade-off costs them later. Others described planning processes running almost entirely by finance and operations, with marketing added only after targets are set. Consistently, marketing was excluded from setting the target, then held accountable for hitting it.
The Cost of Arriving Late
That exclusion has a price, and timing compounds it. Most CMO executives described significant or moderate involvement in board and strategy discussions. But both CMOs and their peers could easily recount specific instances of marketing being looped in only after a major decision was already set.
non-marketing execs identified a major decision where CMO was brought in after key choices were locked
marketing leaders said this happened to them
Both groups cite the fallout: Launches slipped by months, go-to-market plans were paused and reworked, and customer perception issues — that marketing could have anticipated — surfaced only after backlash started. The damage spread well past marketing’s own lane: Technology rollouts needed avoidable rework once customer needs were added after the architecture was locked; a packaging redesign was halted weeks before production sign-off; and one acquisition was delayed because the CMO, who knew the target’s customers were unhappy, was brought in too late.
The business makes a call without information marketing could have contributed, then pays to fix what was missed.
Marketing historically has been considered as a support function, enabler… not focused on strategy… It is changing, but it will take some time.”
— CFO, technology company
What Gets Missed
The cost of involving marketing late is clearest when set against what early involvement delivers. When executives named who owns the organization’s understanding of its customers and growth audiences, marketing was named more than any other function. And notably, customer and market insights were also reported to have directly overturned executive assumptions on product quality, target customer profiles, marketing entry timing, and pricing strategy.
Earlier involvement from marketing is a hedge against bad decisions. The insight already exists inside most organizations. The open question is whether it reaches the table before the decision it would have changed, or after.
Misdiagnosed as a Language Gap
The standard prescription for CMO and C-suite misalignment has become familiar: Speak the language of business, translate marketing into numbers the CFO trusts, and demonstrate fluency in strategy. The advice is sound, but it’s often beside the point. "Communication problems” came up often among responses, but nearly half said communication issues “almost always” mask a deeper disagreement. Very few treated communication as the root cause on its own.
Among non-CMO executives, the most common sources of disagreement was budget allocation and investment priorities, compounded by differing incentives, time horizons, risk tolerance, and standards of evidence. In many organizations, it's unclear who holds final authority on these issues. Marketing may view an investment as groundwork for growth 18 months from now, while finance sees an uncertain return in the current quarter. Both perspectives can be rational, but they lead to different choices. No translation exercise fixes a disagreement that is rooted in competing objectives.
What’s actually driving the disconnect
% of respondents who identified each factor as a source of C-suite misalignment
Chief Marketing Officer
Other C-Suite
Different functional priorities
80%
62%
Strategy, product, pricing, or customer disagreement
65%
51%
Different time horizons or financial priorities
60%
46%
Different risk tolerance or evidence standards
45%
54%
Data or trust gap
50%
36%
Genuine communication or relationship gap
30%
18%
This is a governance failure. Without a clear decision owner, authority defaults to hierarchy, timing, or whoever argues hardest. Too many organizations set the target, hand marketing a budget, ask it to plan backward from the number, then hold it accountable for defending results against a goal it never helped set.
People may understand each other clearly but still disagree because they are optimizing for different business outcomes or working from different data points.”
– CIO, technology company
The fix starts earlier: Ask marketing whether the opportunity is real, build the assumptions jointly, and agree on success measures before the plan is locked. Done this way, the business gets its own customer intelligence into the model before it ships, instead of auditing the miss afterward.
From Practitionersto Business Architects
Leading marketers already understand the value of shifting their role from practitioner to business architect. And yet the research suggests many still struggle to make it stick, held back by a dated view of the discipline inside the C-suite. Three moves can change this:
Marketing must also get out of its own way. When CMOs were asked for the single piece of advice they’d give a peer trying to build credibility with the CEO, CFO, and board, the top answer by a wide margin was some version of speak the language of finance and business outcomes, the same advice the industry has repeated for a decade without closing the gap. CMOs and their peers already understand each other well enough; what will move the needle now is sequencing, clear decision authority, and shared definition of when marketing’s judgment is supposed to count. Getting there means a C-suite willing to treat marketing’s absence from strategy discussions as a problem that should never arise.
Share On LinkedIn
GALE is a Business Agency.
We bring business strategy to brand storytelling to drive enterprise value.
Learn More
The CMOInfluence Gap
How sequencing and the illusion of alignment
are holding marketing back
Created by
With an ever-expanding remit, CMOs are now expected to be futurists, technologists, and operators, overseeing everything from sales enablement and product to customer experience and AI adoption. In theory, that breadth should translate to a bigger role in shaping the business. New research from GALE and NewtonX suggests it hasn’t.
Across C-suite executives – including CMOs, CEOs, CTOs, and CIOs at companies ranging from $100 million to more than $1 billion in revenue – the data tells two different stories depending on which question you ask. Ask about alignment, and the C-suite agrees: 81% of executives rate marketing/C-suite alignment a 4 or 5 out of 5, and CMOs and their peers rate it similarly high. Ask about influence, and that agreement falls apart. While exceptions certainly exist, it reflects a broader problem: Marketing is too often seen as the function that makes the building look good, rather than one that helps build its foundation.
Split on Influence
The gap between the two questions is worth exploring. Nearly three in four marketing leaders rate their influence on major enterprise strategy decisions highly, while only half of their fellow executives agree. Executives broadly report feeling aligned, but far fewer agree that marketing actually moves decisions. That contradiction suggests that presence at the table and participation in the decision are being treated as the same thing by one side of the room and as two different things by the other. The presence data makes the point sharper, and org structure doesn’t explain it away. CMOs report regular board participation at a materially lower rate than their peers (71% vs 92%), despite marketing being this group’s leading named owner of customer and market insights. Marketing holds information the business needs, but it doesn’t consistently have a seat where that information should be leveraged.
Influence of the CMO role on major enterprise strategy decisions
1–5 scale
Rated 5
Rated 4
CMO self-rating (n=21)
43%
28%
71%
Other C-suite rating (n=38)
18%
32%
50%
Architect or Executor
The gap widens at the extremes. Nearly half of marketing leaders rate their own influence a perfect 5, while only 18% of their C-suite peers agree. The divide traces to two incompatible job definitions. CMOs see themselves as architects of strategic direction; peers see a function that executes strategy set elsewhere.
Performance evaluation reflects the same split. Marketing leaders describe a finance-grade scorecard: pipeline, acquisition cost, payback, and lifetime value. Their peers apply a simpler test, either top-line revenue or softer signals like brand recognition and satisfaction, and nearly a third say marketing is judged on soft, qualitative or unclear measures, twice the rate CMOs report.
Strategy is usually set by others in the organization, and they’re helping execute and design around that strategy — not develop the strategy.”
– COO, utilities company
I think from a strategic standpoint…CMO is almost at the bottom, if not the bottom, in the organizations I’ve seen.”
– CIO, automotive company
Some executives admitted to deliberately excluding marketing from key decisions, in the interest of moving faster, for example, even while acknowledging that the trade-off costs them later. Others described planning processes running almost entirely by finance and operations, with marketing added only after targets are set. Consistently, marketing was excluded from setting the target, then held accountable for hitting it.
The Cost of Arriving Late
That exclusion has a price, and timing compounds it. Most CMO executives described significant or moderate involvement in board and strategy discussions. But both CMOs and their peers could easily recount specific instances of marketing being looped in only after a major decision was already set.
non-marketing execs identified a major decision where CMO was brought in after key choices were locked
marketing leaders said this happened to them
Both groups cite the fallout: Launches slipped by months, go-to-market plans were paused and reworked, and customer perception issues — that marketing could have anticipated — surfaced only after backlash started. The damage spread well past marketing’s own lane: Technology rollouts needed avoidable rework once customer needs were added after the architecture was locked; a packaging redesign was halted weeks before production sign-off; and one acquisition was delayed because the CMO, who knew the target’s customers were unhappy, was brought in too late.
The business makes a call without information marketing could have contributed, then pays to fix what was missed.
Marketing historically has been considered as a support function, enabler… not focused on strategy… It is changing, but it will take some time.”
— CFO, technology company
What Gets Missed
The cost of involving marketing late is clearest when set against what early involvement delivers. When executives named who owns the organization’s understanding of its customers and growth audiences, marketing was named more than any other function. And notably, customer and market insights were also reported to have directly overturned executive assumptions on product quality, target customer profiles, marketing entry timing, and pricing strategy.
Earlier involvement from marketing is a hedge against bad decisions. The insight already exists inside most organizations. The open question is whether it reaches the table before the decision it would have changed, or after.
Misdiagnosed as a Language Gap
The standard prescription for CMO and C-suite misalignment has become familiar: Speak the language of business, translate marketing into numbers the CFO trusts, and demonstrate fluency in strategy. The advice is sound, but it’s often beside the point. "Communication problems” came up often among responses, but nearly half said communication issues “almost always” mask a deeper disagreement. Very few treated communication as the root cause on its own.
Among non-CMO executives, the most common sources of disagreement was budget allocation and investment priorities, compounded by differing incentives, time horizons, risk tolerance, and standards of evidence. In many organizations, it's unclear who holds final authority on these issues. Marketing may view an investment as groundwork for growth 18 months from now, while finance sees an uncertain return in the current quarter. Both perspectives can be rational, but they lead to different choices. No translation exercise fixes a disagreement that is rooted in competing objectives.
What’s actually driving the disconnect
% of respondents who identified each factor as a source of C-suite misalignment
Chief Marketing Officer
Other C-Suite
Different functional priorities
80%
62%
Strategy, product, pricing, or customer disagreement
65%
51%
Different time horizons or financial priorities
60%
46%
Different risk tolerance or evidence standards
45%
54%
Data or trust gap
50%
36%
Genuine communication or relationship gap
30%
18%
This is a governance failure. Without a clear decision owner, authority defaults to hierarchy, timing, or whoever argues hardest. Too many organizations set the target, hand marketing a budget, ask it to plan backward from the number, then hold it accountable for defending results against a goal it never helped set.
People may understand each other clearly but still disagree because they are optimizing for different business outcomes or working from different data points.”
– CIO, technology company
The fix starts earlier: Ask marketing whether the opportunity is real, build the assumptions jointly, and agree on success measures before the plan is locked. Done this way, the business gets its own customer intelligence into the model before it ships, instead of auditing the miss afterward.
From Practitionersto Business Architects
Leading marketers already understand the value of shifting their role from practitioner to business architect. And yet the research suggests many still struggle to make it stick, held back by a dated view of the discipline inside the C-suite. Three moves can change this:
Marketing must also get out of its own way. When CMOs were asked for the single piece of advice they’d give a peer trying to build credibility with the CEO, CFO, and board, the top answer by a wide margin was some version of speak the language of finance and business outcomes, the same advice the industry has repeated for a decade without closing the gap. CMOs and their peers already understand each other well enough; what will move the needle now is sequencing, clear decision authority, and shared definition of when marketing’s judgment is supposed to count. Getting there means a C-suite willing to treat marketing’s absence from strategy discussions as a problem that should never arise.
Share On LinkedIn
GALE is a Business Agency.
We bring business strategy to brand storytelling to drive enterprise value.
Learn More
The CMOInfluence Gap
How sequencing and the illusion of alignment
are holding marketing back
Created by
With an ever-expanding remit, CMOs are now expected to be futurists, technologists, and operators, overseeing everything from sales enablement and product to customer experience and AI adoption. In theory, that breadth should translate to a bigger role in shaping the business. New research from GALE and NewtonX suggests it hasn’t.
Across C-suite executives – including CMOs, CEOs, CTOs, and CIOs at companies ranging from $100 million to more than $1 billion in revenue – the data tells two different stories depending on which question you ask. Ask about alignment, and the C-suite agrees: 81% of executives rate marketing/C-suite alignment a 4 or 5 out of 5, and CMOs and their peers rate it similarly high. Ask about influence, and that agreement falls apart. While exceptions certainly exist, it reflects a broader problem: Marketing is too often seen as the function that makes the building look good, rather than one that helps build its foundation.
Split on Influence
The gap between the two questions is worth exploring. Nearly three in four marketing leaders rate their influence on major enterprise strategy decisions highly, while only half of their fellow executives agree. Executives broadly report feeling aligned, but far fewer agree that marketing actually moves decisions. That contradiction suggests that presence at the table and participation in the decision are being treated as the same thing by one side of the room and as two different things by the other. The presence data makes the point sharper, and org structure doesn’t explain it away. CMOs report regular board participation at a materially lower rate than their peers (71% vs 92%), despite marketing being this group’s leading named owner of customer and market insights. Marketing holds information the business needs, but it doesn’t consistently have a seat where that information should be leveraged.
Influence of the CMO role on major enterprise strategy decisions
1–5 scale
Rated 5
Rated 4
CMO self-rating (n=21)
43%
28%
71%
Other C-suite rating (n=38)
18%
32%
50%
Architect or Executor
The gap widens at the extremes. Nearly half of marketing leaders rate their own influence a perfect 5, while only 18% of their C-suite peers agree. The divide traces to two incompatible job definitions. CMOs see themselves as architects of strategic direction; peers see a function that executes strategy set elsewhere.
Performance evaluation reflects the same split. Marketing leaders describe a finance-grade scorecard: pipeline, acquisition cost, payback, and lifetime value. Their peers apply a simpler test, either top-line revenue or softer signals like brand recognition and satisfaction, and nearly a third say marketing is judged on soft, qualitative or unclear measures, twice the rate CMOs report.
Strategy is usually set by others in the organization, and they’re helping execute and design around that strategy — not develop the strategy.”
– COO, utilities company
I think from a strategic standpoint…CMO is almost at the bottom, if not the bottom, in the organizations I’ve seen.”
– CIO, automotive company
Some executives admitted to deliberately excluding marketing from key decisions, in the interest of moving faster, for example, even while acknowledging that the trade-off costs them later. Others described planning processes running almost entirely by finance and operations, with marketing added only after targets are set. Consistently, marketing was excluded from setting the target, then held accountable for hitting it.
The Cost of Arriving Late
That exclusion has a price, and timing compounds it. Most CMO executives described significant or moderate involvement in board and strategy discussions. But both CMOs and their peers could easily recount specific instances of marketing being looped in only after a major decision was already set.
non-marketing execs identified a major decision where CMO was brought in after key choices were locked
marketing leaders said this happened to them
Both groups cite the fallout: Launches slipped by months, go-to-market plans were paused and reworked, and customer perception issues — that marketing could have anticipated — surfaced only after backlash started. The damage spread well past marketing’s own lane: Technology rollouts needed avoidable rework once customer needs were added after the architecture was locked; a packaging redesign was halted weeks before production sign-off; and one acquisition was delayed because the CMO, who knew the target’s customers were unhappy, was brought in too late.
The business makes a call without information marketing could have contributed, then pays to fix what was missed.
Marketing historically has been considered as a support function, enabler… not focused on strategy… It is changing, but it will take some time.”
— CFO, technology company
What Gets Missed
The cost of involving marketing late is clearest when set against what early involvement delivers. When executives named who owns the organization’s understanding of its customers and growth audiences, marketing was named more than any other function. And notably, customer and market insights were also reported to have directly overturned executive assumptions on product quality, target customer profiles, marketing entry timing, and pricing strategy.
Earlier involvement from marketing is a hedge against bad decisions. The insight already exists inside most organizations. The open question is whether it reaches the table before the decision it would have changed, or after.
Misdiagnosed as a Language Gap
The standard prescription for CMO and C-suite misalignment has become familiar: Speak the language of business, translate marketing into numbers the CFO trusts, and demonstrate fluency in strategy. The advice is sound, but it’s often beside the point. "Communication problems” came up often among responses, but nearly half said communication issues “almost always” mask a deeper disagreement. Very few treated communication as the root cause on its own.
Among non-CMO executives, the most common sources of disagreement was budget allocation and investment priorities, compounded by differing incentives, time horizons, risk tolerance, and standards of evidence. In many organizations, it's unclear who holds final authority on these issues. Marketing may view an investment as groundwork for growth 18 months from now, while finance sees an uncertain return in the current quarter. Both perspectives can be rational, but they lead to different choices. No translation exercise fixes a disagreement that is rooted in competing objectives.
What’s actually driving the disconnect
% of respondents who identified each factor as a source of C-suite misalignment
Chief Marketing Officer
Other C-Suite
Different functional priorities
80%
62%
Strategy, product, pricing, or customer disagreement
65%
51%
Different time horizons or financial priorities
60%
46%
Different risk tolerance or evidence standards
45%
54%
Data or trust gap
50%
36%
Genuine communication or relationship gap
30%
18%
This is a governance failure. Without a clear decision owner, authority defaults to hierarchy, timing, or whoever argues hardest. Too many organizations set the target, hand marketing a budget, ask it to plan backward from the number, then hold it accountable for defending results against a goal it never helped set.
People may understand each other clearly but still disagree because they are optimizing for different business outcomes or working from different data points.”
– CIO, technology company
The fix starts earlier: Ask marketing whether the opportunity is real, build the assumptions jointly, and agree on success measures before the plan is locked. Done this way, the business gets its own customer intelligence into the model before it ships, instead of auditing the miss afterward.
From Practitionersto Business Architects
Leading marketers already understand the value of shifting their role from practitioner to business architect. And yet the research suggests many still struggle to make it stick, held back by a dated view of the discipline inside the C-suite. Three moves can change this:
Marketing must also get out of its own way. When CMOs were asked for the single piece of advice they’d give a peer trying to build credibility with the CEO, CFO, and board, the top answer by a wide margin was some version of speak the language of finance and business outcomes, the same advice the industry has repeated for a decade without closing the gap. CMOs and their peers already understand each other well enough; what will move the needle now is sequencing, clear decision authority, and shared definition of when marketing’s judgment is supposed to count. Getting there means a C-suite willing to treat marketing’s absence from strategy discussions as a problem that should never arise.
Share On LinkedIn
GALE is a Business Agency.
We bring business strategy to brand storytelling to drive enterprise value.
Learn More